Samantha Feder LCSW (FL) · RSW (ON) · PSYCHOTHERAPY Free consult
PERFECTIONISM & SELF-WORTH

Perfectionism: when you are harder on yourself than on anyone else

If you are tired of never quite feeling like enough, nothing about you is broken. The voice that pushes so hard may be trying, in its own way, to keep you safe.

Samantha Feder, LCSW (FL) · RSW (ON) · Online therapy in Florida and Ontario
IN SHORT

Perfectionism can be less about high standards and more about fear: the sense that if you get something wrong, something bad will happen or you will be less worthy of love. Many people experience it as a harsh inner critic that is trying, in its own way, to protect them. Therapy can be a space to get curious about that critic rather than fighting it, and to begin relating to yourself with more compassion.

What is perfectionism, really?

Perfectionism can feel very different from the inside than it looks from the outside. You might recognize it in the message you reread six times before sending, in the compliment that slides right off while one small piece of feedback stays with you for days, or in the to-do list that never ends, because every item you cross off makes room for the next one.

There is nothing wrong with caring about your work, your relationships, or the people who rely on you. High standards can come from your values: you want to do something well because it matters to you. Fear-driven standards feel different. They come from the sense that if you get it wrong, something bad will happen. Someone will be disappointed, or you will somehow be less worthy of love and belonging.

High standards usually leave some room for rest, mistakes, and being human. Fear-driven standards rarely do: whatever you reach, the bar quietly moves.

Many people learned somewhere along the way that being good, helpful, capable, or easy was the safest way to belong. Maybe expectations around you were high, maybe love felt like it depended on how you performed, or maybe you were the one who held everything together. Seen in the place where it began, perfectionism can look less like a flaw and more like a way of coping.

Why am I so hard on myself?

If you are kinder to everyone else than to yourself, you are not doing something wrong. Often, the voice that is hardest on you is not trying to hurt you. It may be trying to protect you.

In parts work, we might think of this voice as a part of you: the inner critic, who keeps score so no one else can, or the perfectionist, who believes flawless equals safe. Internal Family Systems (IFS), a model developed by Richard Schwartz, understands parts like these as protectors. Parts often take on protective roles based on what we’ve experienced, sometimes long ago, when getting it right felt like the way to stay safe or keep the peace.

The critic might believe that if it stops pushing, you will fall apart, let people down, or be rejected. Seen that way, its harshness can look less like the truth about you and more like a tired part doing a very hard job.

How are perfectionism and shame connected?

Perfectionism and shame often travel together. Guilt tends to sound like “I did something wrong.” Shame tends to sound like “something is wrong with me.” When a mistake starts to feel like evidence about who you are, it makes sense that a part of you would work so hard to never make one.

Shame says there is something wrong with you for feeling what you feel. There isn’t.

Shame can show up as a harsh inner critic, chronic self-doubt, or the feeling that you’re somehow never quite enough. It can make it hard to ask for help, to rest, or to let anyone see the messy parts. Perfectionism can become a way of staying one step ahead of that feeling, though getting it right rarely quiets shame for long.

You don’t have to earn your worth. It was never meant to be conditional to begin with.

What is “high functioning anxiety”?

“High functioning anxiety” is a phrase many people use to describe a familiar experience: you keep going, you show up, you meet the deadline, and underneath it all there is a steady hum of worry, second-guessing, and bracing for what might go wrong. Your mind may never quite switch off.

It isn’t a diagnosis, and it doesn’t need to be one for what you’re feeling to matter. Some people find the phrase puts words to something they have carried for a long time; others don’t relate to it. Either is okay.

You might recognize some of this:

  • Feeling a wave of dread over a small mistake no one else noticed.
  • Feeling restless or guilty when you try to rest.
  • Planning for every “what if” so nothing can catch you off guard.
  • Hearing praise and quietly thinking, “They just don’t know.”

If you recognize yourself in even one of these, it may be worth paying attention to, not as a flaw, but as information about how much you have been carrying on your own.

How do I stop being a perfectionist?

It is an understandable question, and sometimes it is the perfectionist asking. “How do I stop” can quietly turn into one more thing to get right.

Rather than trying to get rid of the perfectionist part, some people find it more helpful to get to know it. A part that feels understood may not need to push quite so hard.

A few small things some people find helpful:

  • Noticing the voice and naming it. Something as simple as “there’s the critic again” can create a little space between you and it.
  • Getting curious instead of arguing. You might ask it: what are you afraid would happen if I didn’t do this perfectly?
  • Asking where a standard comes from: is this something I value, or something I’m afraid of? Sometimes it’s both.
  • Trying “good enough” somewhere small and low-stakes, and noticing what comes up, in your thoughts and in your body.
  • Speaking to yourself with the same kindness and understanding you’d offer a close friend. It can feel awkward at first, and that’s okay.

There is no right way to do any of these. If they feel hard, that isn’t failure. It may simply mean the part keeping you safe is holding a lot, which can be easier to explore with support.

What does therapy for perfectionism look like?

In our work together, this isn’t about becoming a different person or lowering your standards on command. It’s about the two of us sitting beside each other, getting curious about what the perfectionism is protecting, and making space for greater compassion, clarity, and choice.

We slow things down and notice what happens when the critic shows up, maybe in a meeting or late at night when your mind won’t rest. We don’t try to silence the critic. We get to know it: where it learned its job, what it is afraid of, and what you might need now. In therapy, we explore where these beliefs came from and learn to relate to yourself with more compassion.

IFS-informed parts work is one of the approaches I may draw from, along with mindfulness and self-compassion, and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, which can help you put your energy into what matters most to you rather than wrestling with every difficult thought. We go at a pace that feels safe for you. Healing is not linear, and we revisit what is helping along the way.

Many of the women I work with are exhausted, overthinking everything, and quietly hard on themselves. You don’t have to show up any particular way here.

Sessions are 60 minutes by video, Monday through Thursday, for individuals 18+ in Florida and Ontario, in English or Spanish, from any private space where you can talk freely.

Over time, we keep making space for a gentler, more curious relationship with every part of you, including the relationship you have with yourself.

You don’t have to get this right to begin.

A free 15 minute consult, by video or phone, is a low-pressure way to meet, ask questions, and see how it feels. You don’t need to know exactly what you’re struggling with. There’s nothing you need to prepare, and there’s no obligation at the end.

Book a free 15 minute consult
Sessions Monday to Thursday, by video, across Florida and Ontario.
KEEP READING
Therapy for women →
How therapy with me works, and how to begin.
What IFS therapy is like: parts, Self, and what a session can feel like →
IFS therapy (Internal Family Systems) is an evidence-based approach that understands each of us as having different parts, each trying in its own way to help, along with a calm, curious, compassionate core called Self.
Overthinking: why your mind won't switch off, and what can help →
Overthinking, sometimes called rumination, is when your mind loops on the same worries, conversations, or decisions without landing anywhere new.
People-pleasing and boundaries: why saying no can feel so hard →
People-pleasing is a pattern of putting other people’s needs, moods, and comfort ahead of your own, often so no one gets upset.